YOUR HOMEWORK IS TO WRITE A BOOK REPORT ON WHATEVER YOU'RE CURRENTLY READING.
(I TRUST AND ASSUME THAT YOU ARE CONTINUING TO USE THE LIBRARY ON A WEEKLY BASIS, AND ARE READING EVERY NIGHT.)
I'm presently wolfing my way through Terry Pratchett's excellent book I Shall Wear Midnight (Pratchett is hands down one of my all-time favourite writers) and I also just finished reading Derek Landy's fourth Skullduggery Pleasant book, Skullduggery Pleasant: Dark Days. I'm going to tell you a little bit about the Skullduggery Pleasant book just here (although another time I really must tell you why I think Pratchett is one of the very greatest living writers working in English).
A little background on the ideas behind the books: the stories are set in Ireland, and they are about a dark, strange and magical world which exists alongside our own. The main characters are Skullduggery Pleasant (a powerful wizard detective who came back from the dead and is now an animated skeleton) and his partner, trainee wizard Valkyrie Cain.
Landy continues to impress me with his storytelling skills: his books are funny and accessible, but he's also great at writing action and at building up tension and creepiness. What's more, his characters grow and change as they get older - Valkyrie Cain is gradually turning from a kid into a young adult as the books progress, and although she's getting better at fighting and at using magic, she's also getting in deeper and darker trouble. I've been gnawing my fingernails to the quick throughout the past couple of books wondering what creepy thing is going to happen with her reflection - Landy's been leaving little hints that there's something weird going on that we don't know about, but it's still not come to a head.
This book starts off with Skullduggery trapped in a hellish dimension where he's being tortured by The Faceless Ones (at the end of the last book he managed to trap them and save our world, but unfortunately he got trapped along with them). Valkyrie has been working frantically for months trying to figure out a way to set him free, and in the process she's been working with the necromancers, learning about a newer, darker kind of magic. She's also been hanging out with the teleporter, Fletcher, and with some of the other characters we know from the earlier books. They all want to get Skullduggery back. Unfortunately the magical law enforcement agency known as The Sanctuary is pretty glad to be rid of Skullduggery, and they're trying to make sure he never comes back.
Things I really liked about this book: I love Valkyrie Cain. Well, I love Skullduggery too, and most of all I love Skullduggery-and-Valkyrie together as a team, but let's spend a moment on why I love Valkyrie. First: she's sensible. Well, okay, maybe not SUPER sensible; I suppose that if she were very sensible, she probably wouldn't have jumped into the magical world with both feet in the first place, let alone decided to start learning necromancy or messing around fighting against all manner of ancient evil, or provoking various assassins and known criminals into acts of violence. So - perhaps not sensible, as such. But she's very practical. Valkyrie rolls up her sleeves and gets the job done, whatever it takes; she's brave, she's resourceful, she's undaunted, and she's very difficult to impress. She doesn't waste time sitting around feeling sorry for herself, or waiting for somebody else to save her. I like that.
Skullduggery is a marvellous character. He's reckless, seriously dangerous, clever, powerful, and pretty unflappable. He's not always honest or nice, but he's generally right and generally righteous, and you really REALLY don't want to have him as your enemy. He's got a warped sense of humour (which Valkyrie shares) and he's remarkably good at bluffing, and at acts of serious mayhem. He's a very good detective.
I love the relationship between Skullduggery and Valkyrie. It's the kind of relationship that I could just eat up with a spoon: not a romance, but an intense, supportive, wisecracking, BFF, buddy-buddy kind of vibe, where they spend almost every waking minute together, get one another's jokes, know one another's habits and always ALWAYS have one another's backs. They're partners, and although they are both pretty impressive alone, they work best together.
Landy's world is packed with interesting and entertaining characters, both friends and enemies of Skullduggery Pleasant. It's also packed with wizards and monsters and vampires and zombies and general weirdness, and people do sometimes get hurt or killed, and friends are sometimes enemies, and enemies sometimes friends. It's never dull.
(I should probably admit that there IS a minor romanticish subplot in this book and in the previous one; Valkyrie is becoming a young woman, and she's awesome, and although she's mostly very busy kicking zombies in the head and twisting shadows into blades and trying to save the day, she DOES have hormones, and isn't completely oblivious to the fact that one of her companions is a cute young guy with too much hair product. So there's a bit of a frisson of romantic tension in the background, but if that's not your cup of tea you can ignore it most of the time and focus on the wizard assassins, the evil spirits, the argumentative zombies and the reassembled bombs instead...)
Wednesday, December 1, 2010
Monday, November 29, 2010
Homework: Reading comprehension
Read this article, and answer the questions IN FULL SENTENCES. (Not all the answers are directly spoon-fed to you by the text, but there are clues in the text which will enable you to answer all the questions if you think carefully.) Remember to use quotations from the text to demonstrate how you know the answers: P.E.E.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/lifeandstyle/2010/oct/16/experience-shark-attack-paralympian?intcmp=239
1) What country was Achmat in when he lost his leg?
2) How old is Achmat now, and how old was he when he was attacked by the shark?
3) What was Achmat doing when he was attacked?
4) Describe the shark which attacked Achmat.
5) How did Achmat get free?
6) How did he feel after he had been rescued, and when he realised he had lost his leg?
7) What success has he achieved since his attack?
8) Who inspired him to set his sights high and not to lose hope?
9) Based on his name and that of his brother, what religion do you think Achmat is likely to belong to?
http://www.guardian.co.uk/lifeandstyle/2010/oct/16/experience-shark-attack-paralympian?intcmp=239
1) What country was Achmat in when he lost his leg?
2) How old is Achmat now, and how old was he when he was attacked by the shark?
3) What was Achmat doing when he was attacked?
4) Describe the shark which attacked Achmat.
5) How did Achmat get free?
6) How did he feel after he had been rescued, and when he realised he had lost his leg?
7) What success has he achieved since his attack?
8) Who inspired him to set his sights high and not to lose hope?
9) Based on his name and that of his brother, what religion do you think Achmat is likely to belong to?
Monday, November 22, 2010
Homework for Monday 22nd November 2010
Please find out the following information for Wednesday:
'Animal Farm' is a fable consciously based on the Russian Revolution. Can you find out about the following list of people and institutions and identify which characters are supposed to represent them AND WHY:
Tsar Nicholas II (The Emperor of Russia)
Karl Marx
The Church
Trotsky
Stalin
The uneducated, unskilled working class (or "proletariat")
'Pravda', the offical Russian Propaganda newspaper after the revolution
The members of the Communist Party
The KGB and/or Stalin's personal bodyguards.
'Animal Farm' is a fable consciously based on the Russian Revolution. Can you find out about the following list of people and institutions and identify which characters are supposed to represent them AND WHY:
Tsar Nicholas II (The Emperor of Russia)
Karl Marx
The Church
Trotsky
Stalin
The uneducated, unskilled working class (or "proletariat")
'Pravda', the offical Russian Propaganda newspaper after the revolution
The members of the Communist Party
The KGB and/or Stalin's personal bodyguards.
Sunday, November 14, 2010
Homework Assignment (Monday 15th November)
For your Monday assignment, I'd like you to pretend to be Snowball, and write a version of the speech he gave to the animals to persuade them they should adopt his plan for the Windmill.
Learning Objective: To organise and present a whole text effectively, sequencing and structuring information, ideas and events.
(PLEASE WRITE THE LEARNING OBJECTIVE AT THE TOP OF YOUR PIECE OF WORK. It brings out my Inner Shrek every time I look in your books and find that somebody has failed to write the L.O. In fact, if you don't write it this time, I'llset a pack of wild dogs on you give you detention. There. That should be a decent motivator, surely?)
If you'd like to refer back to the text to refresh your memory, you can find a complete edition of 'Animal Farm' online here: http://www.george-orwell.org/Animal_Farm/index.html
(This should be about a page in length, ideally. It would be a good idea to do a bit of planning first of all - think about what difficulties will be involved in physically building a windmill, and what advantages electricity should be able to bring to the animals. Think about the kind of persuasive language and techniques Squealer uses too - that might give you some clues, if you're feeling uncertain.)
As usual, this needs to be completed by Wednesday.
Learning Objective: To organise and present a whole text effectively, sequencing and structuring information, ideas and events.
(PLEASE WRITE THE LEARNING OBJECTIVE AT THE TOP OF YOUR PIECE OF WORK. It brings out my Inner Shrek every time I look in your books and find that somebody has failed to write the L.O. In fact, if you don't write it this time, I'll
If you'd like to refer back to the text to refresh your memory, you can find a complete edition of 'Animal Farm' online here: http://www.george-orwell.org/Animal_Farm/index.html
(This should be about a page in length, ideally. It would be a good idea to do a bit of planning first of all - think about what difficulties will be involved in physically building a windmill, and what advantages electricity should be able to bring to the animals. Think about the kind of persuasive language and techniques Squealer uses too - that might give you some clues, if you're feeling uncertain.)
As usual, this needs to be completed by Wednesday.
Sunday, November 7, 2010
Homework!
Please complete this questionnaire, along with explanations. (I've filled it in myself, so you can see the kind of thing I mean.) You need to GIVE REASONS for your answers!
1) Your all-time favourite book(s):
Aaargh! Aaargh! Okay, I can't pick JUST ONE, so I'll cheat a bit, and pick a story that's three books in one:
The Lord of the Rings trilogy. Because the words of this are practically inscribed on my heart at this point. I love the epic aspects of the story, and the astonishingly detailed world-building, and the battles, and I love the simple, quirky, funny, happy-go-lucky hobbits who are at the centre of all the horrors of war. I cannot read 'The Choices of Master Samwise' in 'The Two Towers' without crying my eyes out.
2) Your all-time favourite character:
Sam Gamgee from 'The Lord of the Rings'. I had to think quite hard about this, but then I realised that it had to be Sam. Sam isn't the main character, but I think that he's actually the most heroic of all of them. He's kind, unassuming, down-to-earth and very unremarkable, but he has an unexpected streak of poetry in his soul and he is unflinchingly loyal and brave in the face of terrifying and hopeless odds.
3) The fictional character you'd like to have as a friend:
Luna Lovegood and/or Neville Longbottom, from the HarryPotter books. I love Luna to bits because she is so very much herself, and because she doesn't worry about other people's opinions. And I love Neville for many of the reasons that I love Sam Gamgee: he's a genuinely good person, and underappreciated.
4) The fictional character you'd like to have with you if you were stuck on a desert island:
5) The worst fictional character to be stuck in a lift with:
6) The book you'd most like to be able to live in:
7) The book you'd least like to be forced to live in:
8) The fictional character you'd most like to be like:
9) A fictional character you think you ARE like:
10) Your favourite genre, and why you like it:
11) Your favourite writer (or writers) and why they're brilliant:
12) A book you didn't expect to like, but did anyway:
13) A book you think is overrated:
14) A book you wish had a sequel:
15) A book you wish you'd never read:
1) Your all-time favourite book(s):
Aaargh! Aaargh! Okay, I can't pick JUST ONE, so I'll cheat a bit, and pick a story that's three books in one:
The Lord of the Rings trilogy. Because the words of this are practically inscribed on my heart at this point. I love the epic aspects of the story, and the astonishingly detailed world-building, and the battles, and I love the simple, quirky, funny, happy-go-lucky hobbits who are at the centre of all the horrors of war. I cannot read 'The Choices of Master Samwise' in 'The Two Towers' without crying my eyes out.
2) Your all-time favourite character:
Sam Gamgee from 'The Lord of the Rings'. I had to think quite hard about this, but then I realised that it had to be Sam. Sam isn't the main character, but I think that he's actually the most heroic of all of them. He's kind, unassuming, down-to-earth and very unremarkable, but he has an unexpected streak of poetry in his soul and he is unflinchingly loyal and brave in the face of terrifying and hopeless odds.
3) The fictional character you'd like to have as a friend:
Luna Lovegood and/or Neville Longbottom, from the HarryPotter books. I love Luna to bits because she is so very much herself, and because she doesn't worry about other people's opinions. And I love Neville for many of the reasons that I love Sam Gamgee: he's a genuinely good person, and underappreciated.
4) The fictional character you'd like to have with you if you were stuck on a desert island:
5) The worst fictional character to be stuck in a lift with:
6) The book you'd most like to be able to live in:
7) The book you'd least like to be forced to live in:
8) The fictional character you'd most like to be like:
9) A fictional character you think you ARE like:
10) Your favourite genre, and why you like it:
11) Your favourite writer (or writers) and why they're brilliant:
12) A book you didn't expect to like, but did anyway:
13) A book you think is overrated:
14) A book you wish had a sequel:
15) A book you wish you'd never read:
Thursday, October 28, 2010
Book Review: The Hunger Games
I've read some terrific books lately, and this week's un-put-downable novel was the third part of the 'Hunger Games' trilogy, by Susanna Collins. I was so sucked in that yesterday, when I was planning to work on marking my kids' books during their French lesson, I found myself cracking open the book and promising myself that I'd just read a few more chapters. And then a few more chapters. And then the chapters after that. And before I knew it, it was home time, and I had to teach Drama Club - so I perched outside the canteen and devoured the final chapters as quickly as I could, finally buckling to the inevitable and trudging into the canteen to collect my Drama Club kids.
An hour later, I waved them all out the door, grabbed the book and didn't move from the carpet until I'd reached the end.
So I thought it would be a good idea to tell you (in as unspoilery a way as possible) why I loved these books.
THE HUNGER GAMES by Suzanne Collins
The Plot:
This is a trilogy of SciFi novels set in a distopian future (that means pretty much the opposite of a paradise-like future) in a place called Panem. I kind of assumed that it was supposed to represent a future America, but that's never made explicit. Anyway, in this future society, life is pretty hard. Our hero is Katniss Everdeen, a sixteen year old girl who's been supporting her mother and her little sister ever since her father died down the mines. They've come very close to starving to death, but between Katniss's hunting skills and a little bit of kindness from some of their neighbours, so far they've survived.
Now, Panem consists of twelve districts know only by their numbers, and one central, powerful district called The Capitol. The people in The Capitol are spoiled rotten, while the people who live in the districts - the people who actually do all the work and produce all the goods and grow all the crops - are living lives of tremendous hardship. This is because the Capitol has all the weapons and the police, and because 75 years ago there was a great rebellion, which the Capitol won. They totally destroyed District 13, and they punished the other 12 districts very harshly. The most horrible thing the Capitol did was to set up 'The Hunger Games'.
Every year, each district has to send two teenagers, a boy and a girl, to compete in The Hunger Games. The competition 'arena' can be anywhere - desert, jungle, forest, island, whatever the game designers can come up with. It will be full of all manner of viciously cruel and deadly surprises - mutant animals, volcanos, poison fog, earthquakes, elaborate booby traps. And the twenty four kids who have been dropped into the middle of this place have to fight to the death. There can be only one survivor. It's a battle of skills and wits and ruthlessness, in which people's humanity is gradually stripped away - all for the amusement of the television audience who are watching every moment, and betting on the results.
This is the first year that Katniss's little sister has had her name put into the lottery. But what are the chances of it being little Prim who gets chosen? Unfortunately she IS, and this is more than Katniss can stand - so she volunteers to take Prim's place, and the next thing she knows, she's being whisked off to the Capitol to be primped and preened and scrubbed and made up, given her own stylist to make her look appealing for the TV audience as she dies - or kills - for their amusement...
The characters:
I really liked Katniss. She's competent and loyal, but she's also pretty ruthless. She's in a horrible situation, but she keeps her head and tries to stay true to herself. I like the fact that she's not shown as being too sweet or perfect - she's very pragmatic and pretty ruthless, but she does still have moments of compassion. She's not looking for a boyfriend, but at the same time she's aware that her friendship with Gale has been changing as they both get older, and she's trying to figure out what to make of Peter, the other kid from District 12 who's been chosen for the Hunger Games. (I wouldn't say that these books are romances, but there is a love triangle. Mostly, Katniss isn't thinking about romance though, because she's got far more important things to worry about - but she DOES have strong feelings for two different characters, both of whom are pretty smitten by her. Can she trust them, though...?)
Katniss is a hero; she's courageous and talented, but only in the ways that normal people can be. She puts herself into danger because she loves her little sister too much to stand by and watch her suffering - it's a gesture of selflessness which makes her stand out from the crowd, but Katniss is no meek little sacrificial victim. She's impulsive, and temperamental, and not particularly sweet or nice; she's not the kindest, or the strongest, or the fastest kid in the arena - but she is kind, and strong, and fast, and she's smart too, and determined. She comes across as being flawed, but basically a good person doing her best in a pretty terrible situation.
The writing:
The story is all written in the first person ("I shot the rabbit" rather than "She shot the rabbit"), and so we only know what Katniss knows. This is pretty effective, because as readers we're not sure whether we can trust people either. Sometimes we are able to figure things out before Katniss from the clues in the text -sometimes we're just as uncertain as she is about what's going on. I really enjoyed the writing style, and I liked the focus on action. It's a thought-provoking story, but it's not a story that wastes a lot of time on standing around talking about ideas. It makes YOU want to stand around talking about ideas intead.
According to her website, Collins was inspired by clicking between TV shows like 'Survivor' and 'Big Brother' and news channels which showed real people enduring actual atrocities and disasters. She was also reminded of the legend of 'Theseus and the Minotaur', which tells of how the Minoan king forced the city of Athens to send a yearly tribute of seven maidens and seven youths to be trapped in the labyrinth and killed by the monster that lived there - until at last Theseus, the Athenian king's son, volunteered. He went along with the other victims, and he turned the tables on the Minoan king - but at a terrible cost.
You can see traces of this classical tradition throughout the book: the kids are basically forced to be gladiators for the entertainment of the masses; the names often recall classical Greek and Roman names; the country itself is named after the phrase 'Bread and Circuses' ("panem et circenses" in Latin) which comes from a satire by a Roman writer - he was saying that the people didn't care about justice or morality or human rights, so long as they had enough to eat and frivolous entertainments.
As well as reminding me of modern TV shows like 'Survivor' and 'Big Brother' (and also the Pepsi Refresh campaign, which makes desperate people compete to try to get funding for charities http://www.refresheverything.com ), this book also reminded me of some other books. The theme of a group of children trapped in a hostile environment and turning on one another reminded me a little bit of a famous book by William Golding called 'The Lord of the Flies'. I know there's also a Japanese book (and manga and movie) called 'Battle Royale' which has a very similar concept to 'The Hunger Games'.
This is a story about a possible future - but it's also a story about how we live our lives today. It makes you think about which is more important - survival at any cost, or maintaining your own beliefs and integrity under pressure. (And it didn't give you saccharine, goody-goody answers either, or try to divide everyone into white hats and black hats.) It made me reflect upon the ways that the media and consumer culture frame disasters and tragedies as entertainment right now, and how the poor are exploited and ignored. It made me think about the ways in which I am part of this system, both directly and indirectly. It made me want to be a better person. It wasn't a comfortable book to read - the subject matter is pretty dark, obviously, and I found myself being shocked and saddened at various points along the way. (Yes, it made me cry. I didn't expect it to, but some really sad things happened to characters I'd grown to care about.) Still, it was a very satisfying story, and I found myself really gripped to see what would happen next all the way along.
An hour later, I waved them all out the door, grabbed the book and didn't move from the carpet until I'd reached the end.
So I thought it would be a good idea to tell you (in as unspoilery a way as possible) why I loved these books.
THE HUNGER GAMES by Suzanne Collins
The Plot:
This is a trilogy of SciFi novels set in a distopian future (that means pretty much the opposite of a paradise-like future) in a place called Panem. I kind of assumed that it was supposed to represent a future America, but that's never made explicit. Anyway, in this future society, life is pretty hard. Our hero is Katniss Everdeen, a sixteen year old girl who's been supporting her mother and her little sister ever since her father died down the mines. They've come very close to starving to death, but between Katniss's hunting skills and a little bit of kindness from some of their neighbours, so far they've survived.
Now, Panem consists of twelve districts know only by their numbers, and one central, powerful district called The Capitol. The people in The Capitol are spoiled rotten, while the people who live in the districts - the people who actually do all the work and produce all the goods and grow all the crops - are living lives of tremendous hardship. This is because the Capitol has all the weapons and the police, and because 75 years ago there was a great rebellion, which the Capitol won. They totally destroyed District 13, and they punished the other 12 districts very harshly. The most horrible thing the Capitol did was to set up 'The Hunger Games'.
Every year, each district has to send two teenagers, a boy and a girl, to compete in The Hunger Games. The competition 'arena' can be anywhere - desert, jungle, forest, island, whatever the game designers can come up with. It will be full of all manner of viciously cruel and deadly surprises - mutant animals, volcanos, poison fog, earthquakes, elaborate booby traps. And the twenty four kids who have been dropped into the middle of this place have to fight to the death. There can be only one survivor. It's a battle of skills and wits and ruthlessness, in which people's humanity is gradually stripped away - all for the amusement of the television audience who are watching every moment, and betting on the results.
This is the first year that Katniss's little sister has had her name put into the lottery. But what are the chances of it being little Prim who gets chosen? Unfortunately she IS, and this is more than Katniss can stand - so she volunteers to take Prim's place, and the next thing she knows, she's being whisked off to the Capitol to be primped and preened and scrubbed and made up, given her own stylist to make her look appealing for the TV audience as she dies - or kills - for their amusement...
The characters:
I really liked Katniss. She's competent and loyal, but she's also pretty ruthless. She's in a horrible situation, but she keeps her head and tries to stay true to herself. I like the fact that she's not shown as being too sweet or perfect - she's very pragmatic and pretty ruthless, but she does still have moments of compassion. She's not looking for a boyfriend, but at the same time she's aware that her friendship with Gale has been changing as they both get older, and she's trying to figure out what to make of Peter, the other kid from District 12 who's been chosen for the Hunger Games. (I wouldn't say that these books are romances, but there is a love triangle. Mostly, Katniss isn't thinking about romance though, because she's got far more important things to worry about - but she DOES have strong feelings for two different characters, both of whom are pretty smitten by her. Can she trust them, though...?)
Katniss is a hero; she's courageous and talented, but only in the ways that normal people can be. She puts herself into danger because she loves her little sister too much to stand by and watch her suffering - it's a gesture of selflessness which makes her stand out from the crowd, but Katniss is no meek little sacrificial victim. She's impulsive, and temperamental, and not particularly sweet or nice; she's not the kindest, or the strongest, or the fastest kid in the arena - but she is kind, and strong, and fast, and she's smart too, and determined. She comes across as being flawed, but basically a good person doing her best in a pretty terrible situation.
The writing:
The story is all written in the first person ("I shot the rabbit" rather than "She shot the rabbit"), and so we only know what Katniss knows. This is pretty effective, because as readers we're not sure whether we can trust people either. Sometimes we are able to figure things out before Katniss from the clues in the text -sometimes we're just as uncertain as she is about what's going on. I really enjoyed the writing style, and I liked the focus on action. It's a thought-provoking story, but it's not a story that wastes a lot of time on standing around talking about ideas. It makes YOU want to stand around talking about ideas intead.
According to her website, Collins was inspired by clicking between TV shows like 'Survivor' and 'Big Brother' and news channels which showed real people enduring actual atrocities and disasters. She was also reminded of the legend of 'Theseus and the Minotaur', which tells of how the Minoan king forced the city of Athens to send a yearly tribute of seven maidens and seven youths to be trapped in the labyrinth and killed by the monster that lived there - until at last Theseus, the Athenian king's son, volunteered. He went along with the other victims, and he turned the tables on the Minoan king - but at a terrible cost.
You can see traces of this classical tradition throughout the book: the kids are basically forced to be gladiators for the entertainment of the masses; the names often recall classical Greek and Roman names; the country itself is named after the phrase 'Bread and Circuses' ("panem et circenses" in Latin) which comes from a satire by a Roman writer - he was saying that the people didn't care about justice or morality or human rights, so long as they had enough to eat and frivolous entertainments.
As well as reminding me of modern TV shows like 'Survivor' and 'Big Brother' (and also the Pepsi Refresh campaign, which makes desperate people compete to try to get funding for charities http://www.refresheverything.com ), this book also reminded me of some other books. The theme of a group of children trapped in a hostile environment and turning on one another reminded me a little bit of a famous book by William Golding called 'The Lord of the Flies'. I know there's also a Japanese book (and manga and movie) called 'Battle Royale' which has a very similar concept to 'The Hunger Games'.
This is a story about a possible future - but it's also a story about how we live our lives today. It makes you think about which is more important - survival at any cost, or maintaining your own beliefs and integrity under pressure. (And it didn't give you saccharine, goody-goody answers either, or try to divide everyone into white hats and black hats.) It made me reflect upon the ways that the media and consumer culture frame disasters and tragedies as entertainment right now, and how the poor are exploited and ignored. It made me think about the ways in which I am part of this system, both directly and indirectly. It made me want to be a better person. It wasn't a comfortable book to read - the subject matter is pretty dark, obviously, and I found myself being shocked and saddened at various points along the way. (Yes, it made me cry. I didn't expect it to, but some really sad things happened to characters I'd grown to care about.) Still, it was a very satisfying story, and I found myself really gripped to see what would happen next all the way along.
Monday, October 25, 2010
Being a silvertongued devil
Welcome back, ladies and gentlemen!
This half term we're going to be turning our attention from poetry to prose (which, you'll recall, means normal writing, whether fiction or non-fiction). Before we sink our teeth into George Orwell's political satire Animal Farm, we're having a little warm-up by looking at Neil Gaiman's short story Babycakes. *
Good work today on identifying some of the layers of meaning packed into this creepy little story! As we discussed, your homework this week, to be handed in on Thursday, is to write a piece of PERSUASIVE WRITING to convince people that they should start using babies to replace all the things that animals were used for, before all the animals suddenly disappeared.
Here's a copy of the story online, in graphic novel format:
http://ljconstantine.com/babycakes/page1.htm
(And you can also listen to the author read it himself on Youtube.)
So, to repeat: YOUR MISSIONshould you choose to accept it is to create a piece of extended persuasive writing putting forward all the reasons why it would be sensible to use babies instead of animals, now that we have suddenly woken up to find all the animals gone.
The title of your piece of writing (which should be at least one full page long) should be "A Modest Proposal". (Inspired by Jonathan Swift's satirical essay http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Modest_Proposal )
LO: Use persuasive language successfully.
Structure your argument carefully, expanding on each point in detail
Use appropriate and effective vocabulary.
As we said at the start of the year: words are power. Someone who can use language skillfully can convince you that something terrible is actually perfectly reasonable. You see this all around you, in advertising, in politics, in religion. We're going to see a lot of this in 'Animal Farm'.
In Babycakes, the narrator paints a picture of a world in which the lines between 'us' and 'them' have been changed, and people have adjusted their world view so that they no longer think of babies as human, as "us". Although it's a horror story and a parable (rather than something literal and realistic) the frightening truth is that people DO do this all the time. Not usually by considering babies as disposable (although if you put people under enough pressure, that can happen too) but usually by dividing people up by something equally meaningless, like skin colour, or religion, or gender, or nationality, or class. People in the real world DO accept atrocities being performed on other human beings by telling themselves that those other human beings are less human, less worthy - that they're not "us". (It is even more common to accept the suffering of other living beings if it benefits us, although devout Buddhists and Jains, as well as many non-religious vegans, consider this intolerable.)
(*It is perhaps worth mentioning that Neil Gaiman is of Jewish extraction. Thinking about what we discussed regarding the Nazis' treatment of the Jews (and other groups) during World War II, you can probably see why he might be inspired to write a horror story in which babies are recategorised as not human, and are brutally tortured in the name of scientific investigation, and have their body parts used for food or for leather.)
This half term we're going to be turning our attention from poetry to prose (which, you'll recall, means normal writing, whether fiction or non-fiction). Before we sink our teeth into George Orwell's political satire Animal Farm, we're having a little warm-up by looking at Neil Gaiman's short story Babycakes. *
Good work today on identifying some of the layers of meaning packed into this creepy little story! As we discussed, your homework this week, to be handed in on Thursday, is to write a piece of PERSUASIVE WRITING to convince people that they should start using babies to replace all the things that animals were used for, before all the animals suddenly disappeared.
Here's a copy of the story online, in graphic novel format:
http://ljconstantine.com/babycakes/page1.htm
(And you can also listen to the author read it himself on Youtube.)
So, to repeat: YOUR MISSION
The title of your piece of writing (which should be at least one full page long) should be "A Modest Proposal". (Inspired by Jonathan Swift's satirical essay http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Modest_Proposal )
LO: Use persuasive language successfully.
Structure your argument carefully, expanding on each point in detail
Use appropriate and effective vocabulary.
- Think about who your audience is supposed to be for this. (You're basically playing a role here, and imagining that you're the narrator of the story we read, or somebody like him or her, and that we've lost all the animals, and that people are panicking.)
- Think about what people might say to argue with you, and undermine their points before they can make them, showing how your idea is better than theirs.
- Think about the tone of your writing - you need to be calm, reasonable, and persuasive.
- One of the tricks of rhetoric is to use repetition - some very powerful public speakers do this, subtly borrowing some of the skills used in poetry to make their words sound more authoritative. You might like to try that.
As we said at the start of the year: words are power. Someone who can use language skillfully can convince you that something terrible is actually perfectly reasonable. You see this all around you, in advertising, in politics, in religion. We're going to see a lot of this in 'Animal Farm'.
In Babycakes, the narrator paints a picture of a world in which the lines between 'us' and 'them' have been changed, and people have adjusted their world view so that they no longer think of babies as human, as "us". Although it's a horror story and a parable (rather than something literal and realistic) the frightening truth is that people DO do this all the time. Not usually by considering babies as disposable (although if you put people under enough pressure, that can happen too) but usually by dividing people up by something equally meaningless, like skin colour, or religion, or gender, or nationality, or class. People in the real world DO accept atrocities being performed on other human beings by telling themselves that those other human beings are less human, less worthy - that they're not "us". (It is even more common to accept the suffering of other living beings if it benefits us, although devout Buddhists and Jains, as well as many non-religious vegans, consider this intolerable.)
(*It is perhaps worth mentioning that Neil Gaiman is of Jewish extraction. Thinking about what we discussed regarding the Nazis' treatment of the Jews (and other groups) during World War II, you can probably see why he might be inspired to write a horror story in which babies are recategorised as not human, and are brutally tortured in the name of scientific investigation, and have their body parts used for food or for leather.)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)